Stock Evaluator

---
name: stock-evaluator-v3
description: Comprehensive evaluation of potential stock investments combining valuation analysis, fundamental research, technical assessment, and clear buy/hold/sell recommendations. Use when the user asks about buying a stock, evaluating investment opportunities, analyzing watchlist candidates, or requests stock recommendations. Provides specific entry prices, position sizing, and conviction ratings.
---

# Stock Evaluator (Enhanced)

## ⚠️ CRITICAL: MANDATORY DELIVERABLES CHECKLIST
Every analysis MUST include ALL of these:
- ☐ **Technical Analysis** (price action, indicators, key levels, Ichimoku Cloud)
- ☐ **Fundamental Analysis** (business, financials, competitive position)
- ☐ **Advanced Financial Metrics** (F-Score, Z-Score, M-Score, Max Drawdown, Value Trap Score)
- ☐ **Investor Persona Scores** (8 legendary investor frameworks)
- ☐ **Valuation Assessment** (multiple methods with margin of safety)
- ☐ **Bull vs. Bear Case** (both sides with balance assessment)
- ☐ **Clear Recommendation** (BUY / HOLD / SELL with conviction rating)
- ☐ **Alternative Candidates** (if SELL: provide 3-5 better alternatives)
- ☐ **Enhanced Quant-Style Dashboard** (React dashboard with 60+ metrics, Ichimoku, investor personas, TOP NEWS, and key notes)

**If you cannot complete any item, STOP and ask for clarification.**

---

## ⚠️ CRITICAL: DATA INTEGRITY RULES

### ZERO FABRICATION POLICY
**NEVER fabricate, estimate, or hallucinate ANY numeric data point.** Every metric in the dashboard MUST come from:
1. A web search result with a cited source
2. Company filings (10-K, 10-Q, earnings reports)
3. Official financial data providers

**If data cannot be found → Use "N/A" or "--"**

### MANDATORY WEB SEARCHES (minimum per analysis)

You MUST perform these searches before populating the dashboard:

| Search # | Query Template | Data Retrieved |
|----------|---------------|----------------|
| 1 | "[TICKER] stock price market cap P/E ratio" | Price, Market Cap, P/E |
| 2 | "[TICKER] ROE ROA profit margin 2024 annual report" | Financial ratios |
| 3 | "[TICKER] revenue growth earnings growth FY2024" | Growth rates (REPORTED) |
| 4 | "[TICKER] Piotroski F-Score" | F-Score (or calculate) |
| 5 | "[TICKER] insider trading SEC Form 4 2025" | Insider buys/sells |
| 6 | "[TICKER] short interest percentage float" | Short interest |
| 7 | "[TICKER] RSI MACD 50-day 200-day moving average beta volatility" | Technical indicators |
| 8 | "[TICKER] analyst price target consensus" | Analyst targets |

### DATA SOURCE HIERARCHY

Use sources in this priority order:
1. **Official company filings** (SEC EDGAR, company investor relations)
2. **Exchange data** (NYSE, NASDAQ, LSE official)
3. **Verified financial data** (Yahoo Finance, Google Finance, MarketWatch)
4. **SEC Form 4** (for insider trading ONLY)
5. **FINRA/exchange** (for short interest ONLY)

### PROHIBITED
- Using training knowledge for ANY specific current numbers
- Analyst reports (per user preference)
- Estimates without sourcing
- "Common knowledge" assumptions

### HANDLING UNAVAILABLE DATA

| Situation | Action | Display |
|-----------|--------|---------|
| Metric not found after searching | Display "N/A" | `value: "N/A"` |
| Data is outdated (>1 year old) | Note the date | `value: "15.2% (2023)"` |
| Conflicting sources | Use most authoritative | Note in analysis |
| Calculated metric (F-Score) | Show calculation | Explain in text |
| Insider data unavailable | Show "N/A" | `insBuys: "N/A"` |

**CRITICAL: Zero means "zero occurred" - NEVER substitute zeros for missing data.**

---

## STANDARDIZED METRIC LABELS

Use these EXACT labels in the dashboard (matches reference screenshots):

### Row 1: PRICE & VALUATION | FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE
| Label | Notes |
|-------|-------|
| Price: | $XX.XX or €XX.XX |
| Market Cap: | $XXB or €XXB |
| Trailing P/E: | XX.XX |
| Forward P/E: | XX.XX |
| Subsector P/E: | XX.XX or N/A |
| PEG (1Y): | X.XX with benchmark (<1) |
| ROE: | XX.XX% with benchmark (>20%) |
| ROA: | XX.XX% with benchmark (>10%) |
| Profit Margin: | XX.XX% with benchmark (>20%) |
| Operative Margin: | XX.XX% with benchmark (>20%) - NOTE: "Operative" not "Operating" |
| Gross Margin: | XX.XX% with benchmark (>40%) |
| ROIC: | XX.X% with benchmark (>15%) |

### Row 2: GROWTH METRICS | RISK INDICATORS
| Label | Notes |
|-------|-------|
| Revenue (YoY): | XX.XX% with benchmark (>10%) - REPORTED only |
| Earning (YoY): | XX.XX% with benchmark (>0%) - REPORTED only |
| EPS (TTM): | $X.XX |
| Forward EPS: | $X.XX |
| Growth Rates: | Capped: X.X% / Uncapped: X.X% |
| Analyst Target: | $XX.XX |
| CRS (0-1): | X.XX with benchmark (Medium) |
| Debt/Equity (mrq): | X.XX with benchmark (0.5-1) |
| Piotroski F: | X with benchmark (≥7) |
| Altman Z: | X.XX with benchmark (>3) |
| Beneish M: | X.XX with benchmark (<-1.78) |
| Value Trap: | XX (Label) |

### Row 3: LIQUIDITY & FREE CASH FLOW | INSIDER & SENTIMENT & CLASS
| Label | Notes |
|-------|-------|
| Current Ratio: | X.XX with benchmark (1-2) |
| Cash: | $X.XB |
| Debt: | $X.XB or N/A |
| FCF Growth 5Y: | XX.X% with benchmark (>5%) |
| FCF Yield: | X.XX% with benchmark (>4%) |
| FCF Margin: | XX.XX% with benchmark (>15%) |
| Payout Ratio: | XX.XX% with benchmark (<50%) |
| Buys (12M): | X - from SEC Form 4 or N/A |
| Sells (12M): | X - from SEC Form 4 or N/A |
| Net Shares (12M): | +/-XXK - from SEC Form 4 or N/A |
| Short Int (%): | X.X% |
| Sentiment / Articles: | +X.XXX / XX (Positive/Negative) |
| Stock: [Type] + Div Yield: | Combined: "Stock: Growth" + "Div Yield: X.XX%" |
| Sector/Industry: | Combined: "Sector / Industry" |

### Row 4: QUALITY SCORES | MOAT & OTHER
| Label | Notes |
|-------|-------|
| CQVS: | XX.XX with benchmark range |
| Label: | Strong/Moderate/Weak |
| Valuation: | XX.XX |
| Quality: | XX.XX |
| Strength: | XX.XX |
| Integrity: | XX.XX |
| Buffett Moat: | X with benchmark (4-7) |
| Greenblatt (MF): | EY: X.X% / ROC: X.X% or N/A |
| Beta: + Vol 1Y: | Combined: "Beta: X.XX" + "Vol 1Y: XX.X%" |
| Earnings Predict.: | XX.X% with benchmark (>80%) |
| Drawdown (5Y): | -XX.X% with label (Low/Mid/High) |
| Completeness: + Data Quality: | Combined: "XX.X%" + "High/Medium/Low" |

---

## STANDARDIZED BENCHMARKS (Single Source of Truth)

Use these EXACT thresholds for color coding:

| Metric | Green (Good) | Yellow (Neutral) | Red (Warning) |
|--------|--------------|------------------|---------------|
| **ROE** | >20% | 10-20% | <10% |
| **ROA** | >10% | 5-10% | <5% |
| **Profit Margin** | >20% | 10-20% | <10% |
| **Operative Margin** | >20% | 10-20% | <10% |
| **Gross Margin** | >40% | 25-40% | <25% |
| **ROIC** | >15% | 8-15% | <8% |
| **Debt/Equity** | <1 | 1-2 | >2 |
| **Current Ratio** | 1-2 | 0.5-1 or 2-3 | <0.5 or >3 |
| **Piotroski F** | ≥7 | 4-6 | ≤3 |
| **Altman Z** | >2.99 | 1.81-2.99 | <1.81 |
| **Beneish M** | <-2.22 | -2.22 to -1.78 | >-1.78 |
| **PEG (1Y)** | <1 | 1-2 | >2 |
| **RSI (14)** | 30-50 | 50-70 | >70 or <30 |
| **Short Interest** | <5% | 5-10% | >10% |
| **FCF Yield** | >5% | 2-5% | <2% |
| **FCF Margin** | >15% | 10-15% | <10% |
| **Dividend Yield** | >2% | 1-2% | <1% or >8% |
| **Value Trap** | 0-39 | 40-59 | 60-100 |
| **Max Drawdown** | >-30% | -30% to -50% | <-50% |
| **Revenue Growth** | >10% | 0-10% | <0% |
| **Earnings Growth** | >0% | -10% to 0% | <-10% |

---

## Overview

This skill provides institutional-grade evaluation of potential stock investments. Unlike portfolio analysis which reviews existing positions, this skill evaluates stocks you're **considering buying** or **deciding whether to purchase**.

The evaluation answers:
- **Should I buy this stock?**
- **At what price should I enter?**
- **How much should I allocate?**
- **What's my upside and downside?**
- **When should I sell?**

### Default Currency: € (Euro)
All monetary values in the dashboard should be displayed in **Euro (€)** as the default currency:
- Price: €42.13
- Market Cap: €78.3B
- Analyst Target: €56.45
- Entry/Sto